The Silver Tray was first established about 1935 at 604 Front Street. A picture of that location can be seen to the right. This was the former location of Bland and Bland. Next door to the east was Shotwell's Clothiers.

By 1943, the Silver Tray had moved to 514 NP Avenue as can be seen in the matchbook below.

Sometime in the 1950's or 1960's, the Silver Tray moved to 408 Broadway but it was gone forever in the late 1970s.